
This goes to prove that even IIMs are not perfect . Even they do err ... and in this case they surely did ..!!!
This is so called "IIMs new admission policy for higher class diversity" ... Damn it .. Just awarding 2.5 marks if you are from a non-engineering background can not be justified ... Not by far ... This is a clear cut case of discrimination and I believe this is a way of IIM-L people saying that "We don't want engineers ... We don't want all the perfect students ... We need a diversity ... So this time around we are giving preference to a bunch of less deserving students to make our environment a bit more of fun ... " ...
I mean how could you just give such an unfair advantage to someone from a particular background . If they think that CAT gives an unfair advantage to engineers .. then damn it ... change the bloody question pattern ... change the entire take in process ... instead of devising worthless tools like this ...
If you want people from different backgrounds ... then reserve seats for them ... at least make the picture clear ... at let us know that "Look ... these are the number of seats we have reserved for you "engineers" ... go fight for these to grab a place along with other guys who are enjoying a "much deserved" relaxation in marks " ... I can sense hypocrisy sprayed all over the controversial issue ...!!! ... May be IIM-L was bored of the normal routine intake and decided to play a game of dies for fun ...!!!
A valid bias can never be considered a valid criterion ... Just depriving engineers from those 2.5 marks just because they have been performing well in CAT .. year after year ... can not by justified even if they put forward some divine reason to defend their cause ....
Thumbs Down ..!!!
Rules keep changing year after year.. not talking abt CAT .. coz I know nothing abt this.. but I know other things.. how ppl get depressed coz of sudden implementation of "new points" and "reservations" and what I am referring to is regarding a job criteria in a Govt sector .. ppl possess some qualifications infact they undergo that training just to grab the job, and after 2 years of full fledge training and another couple of years of wait.. when they just think that.. here goes my chance this time.. in this employment notification, boom goes the news that the "criteria has changed" ...
Guess what ... I am not depressed much by this ... Infact I am proud ... that they have accepted wide and open that non engineers need an extra favor to stand in line with us engineers ... ;) ;) ;)
All the best anyway ;-)
I think it is just to encourage non-engineers to take up MBA :smile:
still ... super dislike x-(